Recently, an incident occurred that still has me fuming to
this very moment. Never, in the past 8 months that I have been blogging, would
have predicted that an occurrence like this would ever occur. Naturally, being
the naïve girl I am.
Some, upon reading this blog post, may assume that I am
overreacting. Causing drama. Being a meanie. Well, you obviously don’t take
plagiarism as seriously as I do.
Writers, and us bloggers more specifically, take our work
very seriously. For this reason, we tend to get enraged by an event like this.
An event in which a fellow book blogger/reviewer copied my review practically
verbatim --with a little paraphrasing here and there-- and called it her
own work.
I won’t name any names; but I will include the review of
this particular person.
It began as I was browsing the reviews for a book I had
recently read. I came across said review, and noticed that it sounded oddly
familiar. After a few reads of the review, it hit me that it was just like my
review. Stupidly, I assumed that I had somehow mistakenly copied that review,
but when I looked at the date, it had been published four days after my review
was written.
So, I decided to handle the issue in a polite, mature
manner. I informed the reviewer that she had copied my review. She then replied
that she didn’t copy it, and that people “share opinions” on books. Because I
have no life, I broke down our reviews bit by bit, compared the two, and explained
why it was plagiarism. She even said that all reviewers do this, and that if “this
is copying, then all reviews are plagiarized.” As expected, she repeatedly
denied what would be obvious to anyone comparing the two reviews. I kept
attempting to explain to her that this is plagiarism, plagiarism is wrong.
Clearly, it fell upon deaf ears.
However, the author did delete her review. That’s not to say
that she admitted to her fault or anything.
The reason why I am making such a big spectacle out of this
is because I want to make it known that plagiarism will not be tolerated by
anyone under any circumstance. And the fact that a fellow book blogger did something
like this? That is just sickening and brings shame upon us book bloggers’
names.
I want to make it clear; there is a difference between “sharing
opinions with others” and plagiarizing off another person. This is called
plagiarizing:
My review:
“More like 2.5 stars.
It seems that I've been cursed for the past few weeks or so, as I have read
some pretty horrible books. This book wasn't exactly horrible, but I
didn't enjoy myself while reading this.
I understand that this is an ARC, but there are way too many spelling
and grammatical mistakes, to the point where it distracted me from the plot. I
can't count how many times 'your' and 'you're' were mixed up.
At the beginning of every chapter, there was a few pages of back-story on the Fae.
In my opinion, they were a bit useless. The only thing they achieved in doing
was that it prevented the plot from moving forward, and nothing really happens
until the very end.
It was frustrating how much Caroline kept denying Devilyn's feelings. She
noticed and acknowledged them one second, then the next, she would be
questioning whether or not he liked her. It got pretty annoying.
One thing I don't understand was why Devilyn took so long to actually tell her
of her heritage. Ultimately, it would have kept her safe, and would have
prevented a lot of the bad stuff from occurring. Really, why put it off?
Heck, I'm starting to think the author did this just to cause other events to
happen and to complicate the plot. In reality, it could have all been prevented very easily,
and I found it hard to take the story seriously.
Devilyn was annoying as well. All he spoke of was Caroline, Caroline, Caroline.
Dude, obsessive much? That’s pretty much all that ensued during his point of
view.
My main pet peeve: There was a lot of high school stereotyping here.
A lot. Not everyone who is a cheerleader/jock is a total jerk, FYI.
With a slow-moving plot and characters that I feel indifferent to, I find it
hard to give this book higher than 3 stars. It wasn't very entertaining, and
didn't make good use of the topic of the Fae as much as I had hoped
it would.”
Her review:
“To be clear, this book wasn't bad. The prologue really
pulled me in and the story was very interesting and pretty cool too, but I just
can't get around all the typos. I know, this is an ARC but still. If you ask
me, most of the typos have to be gone in the ARC copies.
Next to that, I liked the background stories you got on the fae before each
chapter, but it was a bit useless. They were really interesting and
fascinating, but they prevent the other plot from moving forward.
I didn't like the characters that much either. Caroline just frustrates me most
of the time. The way she kept denying Devilyn's feelings over and over again.
One moment she acknowledged them and the next she's questioning him again.
Really really annoying and frustrating. And why it took Devilyn so long to tell
her about her heritage, I'll never understand. And he was a bit obsessive. The
main thing he talked about in his POV was Caroline.
Then you got the High School stereotypes. Those are one big no for me.
I feel like this book could have been much better. It was a good idea, good
story, just poorly executed.”
What do you guys think about this entire problem? Do you
think something like this should be made public, or ignored?
